English Version Force de Défense d'Israel sur Internet
Inscription gratuite
AccueilInfos IsraelBlogs Juifs et IsraéliensVidéo IsraelOpinions : monde Juif et IsraelLe MagTOP SitesLa BoutiqueJuif.org TV

Blog : Philosémitisme

Un Cardinal prétend que les Allemands ont souffert plus que les Juifs pendant la Shoah

Le cardinal George Pell a également affirmé que "le petit peuple juif" était composé de bergers moralement et intellectuellement inférieurs aux Égyptiens de l'antiquité.  Son éminence s'est empressée (ça fait partie du script) de présenter ses excuses et d'affirmer sa grande amitié pour le peuple juif.  Il est vrai que l'abbé Pierre diffamait allègrement les Juifs et ne s'est jamais excusé. On aimerait savoir si le cardinal pensent que les Gitans (que les catholiques oublient toujours de mentionner) ont aussi moins souffert que les Allemands.

(JTA) -- The head of Australia's Catholic Church apologized for what Jewish leaders described as "deeply problematical" comments he made about Jews on a TV show.

Cardinal George Pell had said during an April 10 debate with the British atheist Richard Dawkins on "Q&A," a highly regarded current affairs talk show on the Australian Broadcasting Corp., that Germans suffered more than Jews during the Holocaust.


Asked why God allowed the Holocaust to occur, Pell said, "He helped probably through secondary causes for the Jews to escape and continue. It is interesting through these secondary causes probably no people in history have been punished the way the Germans were. It is a terrible mystery."  When challenged by the moderator that the Jews had suffered more, Pell said, "Yes, that might be right. Certainly the suffering in both, I mean the Jews, there was no reason why they should suffer."  Pell said the Holocaust was "a crime unique in history for the death and suffering it caused and its diabolical attempt to wipe out an entire people."

Earlier in the debate Pell said that "the little Jewish people" were shepherds who were morally and intellectually inferior to the ancient Egyptians.

In his clarifying statement, Pell said, "My commitment to friendship with the Jewish community and my esteem for the Jewish faith is a matter of public record, and the last thing I would want to do is give offense to either."

Peter Wertheim, executive director of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry, said the council had expressed "serious concern" about some of Pell's "deeply problematical" comments.

Wertheim added that "We welcome as a first step Cardinal Pell's clarifying statement that he did not intend any offense, and his expression of continuing friendship with the Jewish community and esteem for the Jewish faith."
8 commentaires
Le compte de ce membre a été suspendu.
Envoyé par Johanan - le Mardi 17 Avril 2012 à 19:17
Comment addressed to Cardinal George Pell: (a) We have a saying here that as long as a person keeps his mouth shut everyone will think he's intelligent. Once he does open his mouth, everyone realizes that he's a total nitwit (please read this as 'cum-brained') and retard... reflect on this before making other future declarations; (b) your oh so ' honest, ethical, moralist, spiritual' Church and Vatican are the very cause of the persecutions we have endured throughout the ages; (c) if you had studied your own history you would have seen that today's Church was founded by a bunch of gangster and renegade " knights" or "cavaliers" who blackmailed the credulous/superstitious Italian people to hand over whatever values and/or property they had, besides rigging up polls to elect a ' Pope' from among them; (d) allegedly we Jews "killed" YOUR god; now, if he is a true and real god how can mere human beings even come near him, let alone kill? (e) the Church instituted an Inquisition as a pretext to confiscate every single item it could from the Jews, besides turning away the peoples' rage and reaction from all the corruption and thievery it practiced, finding a convenient scapegoat -US JEWS- ; (f) in the name of YOUR god the Church and the Crusaders committed the most horrendous crimes against us, equal to none other except for those in the Holocaust; (g) you should also have commented, on Pope Pius's XII role before, during and after WWII ... (continues....)
Envoyé par S. - le Mercredi 18 Avril 2012 à 05:58
(continuation...) and also about Pope Pius’s IX kidnapping and converting to Catholicism the Italian Jewish boy Edgardo Mortada and playing “hide-and-seek” with him beneath his papal robes; (h) You should also have commented on all the property stolen from the two Great Temples and Synagogues, which allegedly can be found in the Vatican’s underground chambers; (i) also omitted were the details and stories known and published world-wide on your pedophilic ministers, bishops, priests besides the sexual
intercourses going on in your monasteries! (j)Why didn’t you largely expose the burning of churches, murders and persecutions against Christians, Copts and Catholics prevailing today in all the Moslem-majority countries from the Atlantic to the Sea of China? (k) Last but not least how about the ‘ethnic cleansing’ tried by the Turks against the Armenians? Aren’t Armenians also Christians?
Yes Mr. Cardinal GEorge Pell, it would have been far better for you to ponder and think longer before insulting and injuring us Jews!
S. LEVY

Envoyé par S. - le Mercredi 18 Avril 2012 à 05:59
Ca alors, seulement le titre et déjà j'envie de vomir, !
Envoyé par Julia - le Mercredi 18 Avril 2012 à 07:43
Oui Julia, moi aussi, lorsque je lis le titre de cet article, j'ai également la nausée....Rien n'arrête ces anti-sémites pervers qui ne cessent de faire le déni de la Shoah sous toutes ses formes.

Ils seront punis gravement pour tout cette haine déversée contre nous depuis trop longtemps.. Just wait and see!!!!

AM ISRAEL HAY
Envoyé par Viviane_005 - le Mercredi 18 Avril 2012 à 09:06
Mes amis,Viviane,Julia,Edmond,et touti quanti,
Ce défroqué cardinal,devrait recevoir des coups de poings cardinaux de ma part ,et de vous ,pour lui remettre les idées en place,que tout ce qu'il raconte est un tissu de mensonges ,inepties,contre vérités,bref ,que c'est un âne,quand il prétend,je cite,les bergers israêliens intellectuellement inférieurs aux égyptiens,c'est claaaaaaaaaaaaoui!!!C'est un gros raciste antisémite,un nul de chez nul!!! Embarrassé Embarrassé Embarrassé En colère ! En colère ! En colère ! Triste Triste TristeAM ISRAËL HAI
Envoyé par Yannick_004 - le Mercredi 18 Avril 2012 à 09:24
Oui mes amis, vous toutes et tous, nos sommes confrontes a des heures penibles, haineuses, meurtrieres, ou les Juifs sont concasses comme les olives, la haine dans tout son splendeur, ont voie de heure en heure une pluie insesant de mensoges, des crimen, des bastonades, des injures, tout et la rien echappe, ni grand, ni petit, religieux ou laique, se abattre sur Israêl , les Juifs ou ils se trouvent, , qu' ils soyent punis pour tout le mal qui causen. Et comme vous , tous et toutes qui soutenez Israêl et la communete juive dans de moment si difficil que vous soyez béni et protege par le gardien d'Israêl , le Maître du Monde.
AM ISRAEL HAY !
Envoyé par Julia - le Mercredi 18 Avril 2012 à 12:09
Surement ce ctholique est antisemite et sans foi ni loi s'il se permet d'affirmer ce qui n'a pas de fondement. Le sens chrétien lui manque et cela est très décevant pour celui qui est appelé à précher la vérité. Pitié.
Dales M.
Envoyé par Dales - le Mercredi 18 Avril 2012 à 16:25
Membre Juif.org





Dernière mise à jour, il y a 31 minutes